You Don’t Have To Be Thankful

Photo by Metin Ozer on Unsplash


Wonder Anew is a new recurring section of the Church Anew blog, intended for spiritually curious readers who want to explore the Christian faith with honesty, depth, and imagination. Read here and on our Substack.

Eight years ago, I sat around a Thanksgiving table with my family to share a meal together. It was much like the ones many of us will sit around in a few weeks, with one notable difference: I was not filled with gratitude, but a kind of bitterness. It had been a particularly hard year and I was still reeling, processing, and grieving. 

I wasn’t sure how to feel exactly, but one thing I knew for sure was that I was definitely not grateful. Not at all. Not even a little bit. 

I was angry, I was sad, and I was a little broken, but I was not grateful. I did not, as the Apostle Paul recommended, feel like “giving thanks in all circumstances.” So of course, as it does every year, the time came to share what we were thankful for, and everyone went around saying just lovely and thoughtful things and when it came to me, I grouched out “I’m not thankful for anything this year.” 

Cue the Debbie Downer trombone: womp womp. Yeah - it wasn’t great for the vibe. 

But it was honest. 

I think about this particular moment every year as Thanksgiving nears. 

I could have pretended. I could have performed gratitude and made everyone happy.

But I didn’t. I’m glad I didn’t. 

Just because this is the time of year we’re “supposed” to feel gratitude doesn’t mean we have to. You don't have to be thankful.

You don’t have to be grateful just because it’s Thanksgiving. 

Now, maybe you’re doing really great. 

Maybe you DO have a lot to be grateful for. 

I can answer that “Thanksgiving table question” differently this year than I did back in 2018. Despite not everything around me being perfectly shiny and happy, I have had a year that I am grateful for.

You don't have to be thankful.

But if you are having a particularly hard year, or if you’re finding it hard to find the good in the midst of a lot of difficulty, fear, anxiety, grief, loss, or some combination of all of those, 

I hope you’ll hear me say: you don’t have to. 

You don’t have to find the good. 

You don’t have to dig deep to find gratitude.
You don’t have to perform being ok if you’re not ok. 

All over scripture, there are stories of God drawing close to real and honest feelings.
Stories of God being near to those who aren’t feeling particularly happy and shiny. 

Near to them maybe even because they’re not happy and shiny. 

The Psalms are chock full of yelling at God and crying at God and with God and calling out for help and care and presence and and and. These are real feelings. And God doesn’t berate anyone for their feelings, but instead draws near.

Jesus tells the gathered crowd on the Mount of Beatitudes that those who are grieving and those who are persecuted and those who are poor in spirit are all blessed. Not minimized. Not told to buck up or to get over it, but blessed. They don’t have to be thankful for the good things first, but blessed as they are, with all their feelings and lack of gratitude mixed right in. 

Even in the text that most churches read on the night before Thanksgiving, about the 10 men who were healed but only one came back to thank Jesus, Jesus doesn’t condemn the ones who didn’t come back. He honors the one who did. Gratitude matters, but faking it might be worse than not offering it at all. 

So you can be honest and real. God welcomes it. (and so do I)

If your gratitude is overflowing, then by all means, celebrate - God is there. 

But if your gratitude is hard to find this year,
know you’re not the only one, and God is there too.


Natalia Terfa

Natalia is a Lutheran pastor, podcaster, and author who lives in Minneapolis with her her loves, Sam and Layla, and kitty babies. When she’s not working or writing, you’ll find her reading in her couch nest, ideally with a cat on her lap, watching Turkish television, taking walks in the neighborhood, looking at trees, or making good food for the people she loves.

Next
Next

In Defense of Christ the King Sunday